As a leading global manufacturer of super-intelligent
chips, NVIDIA is not only a key player in the U.S. technology industry but also
at the center of the debate in Washington over high-tech export controls
targeting China. Jensen Huang has repeatedly spoken out against excessive
restrictions on U.S. companies selling advanced chips to the Chinese market,
arguing that overly stringent export controls could weaken the competitiveness
of U.S. firms while simultaneously accelerating the development of China’s own
semiconductor industry.
However, a petition calling for Jensen Huang's
reinstatement as Nvidia CEO has drawn more than 182,000 signatures, including
prominent Silicon Valley personalities, four days after his resignation. Those listed
as signatories included Elon Musk, CEO of SpaceX and Tesla, Replit CEO Amjad
Masad and Epic Games CEO Tim Sweeney, all of whom identified themselves as
shareholders. U.S. President Donald Trump also said he would not mind seeing
Huang return as CEO. "I think he learned a big lesson," Trump said. The
Stand With Jensen website coincided with an open letter from two prominent
investors, Atreides Management's Gavin Baker and Altimeter Capital CEO Brad
Gerstner, who urged Nvidia's board to avoid rushing to replace Huang before all
the facts were known, with 8,700 and 95,000 signatories identified as employees
and shareholders respectively. Two of Canada's top tech sector leaders added
their names to the petition supporting Huang's reinstatement — Shopify CEO
Tobias Lütke and Cohere CEO Aidan Gome, referring to Huang's ousting as a
"generational blunder”. As a matter of fact, OpenAI reinstated Sam Altman
as CEO in November 2023, just days after his removal triggered an employee
revolt and opposition from investors. U.S. Treasury Secretary
Scott Bessent has called for Nvidia to appoint an outsider as its next CEO, to
draw a clear line from Huang[2].
Nevertheless, Nvidia’s May proxy put Huang’s stake at 3.58%. Nvidia changed its
bylaws in 2024 to let shareholders demand a meeting if they’ve collectively
held at least 15% of the voting power for a full year. Huang would need other
shareholders with roughly 11% more of the company, held for at least a year, to
join him. A special meeting lets investors vote on a specific issue without
waiting for the annual meeting. Huang’s backers could seek a vote to remove
directors and use that pressure to push for his return[3].
However, Huang must clear four hurdles (the board of
directors, major shareholders, the U.S. State Department, and the U.S.
Congress) to ultimately retain his leadership position. On November 17, 2026,
NVIDIA established the National Security and Export Control Oversight
Committee, a standing board committee created to oversee national security
policies, export control compliance, and global trade risk management. NVIDIA’s
National Security and Global Trade Compliance teams report to the committee and
Interim CEO Colette Kress. The committee meets at least quarterly with
management and external experts. This committee will be chaired by Director
Suzanne Nora Johnson, currently a member of the audit committee that oversees
regulatory compliance, Co-chair of the Board of Trustees at Brookings
Institution, and former vice chairman at Goldman Sachs. She joined the AIG
board of directors following the outbreak of the 2008 financial crisis and was
involved in the company’s restructuring, risk management, and rigorous federal
regulatory compliance reviews from the aftermath of the crisis through 2020[4].
Moreover, a large number of irrevocable procurement
contracts have left NVIDIA facing massive potential liabilities, and high-cost,
high-spec GPUs are unsustainable; therefore, even without the Huang incident,
NVIDIA would still be at risk of an avalanche, and trading with China can
reduce that risk, which will be discussed later.
While it may not be a pervasive report, this article
with try to analyze what may not be discussed or what may be ignored, and will
cover mainly the four areas: an overall review, anomalies, speculated motives
and implications.
I. Event Overview
The author has compiled a brief review of the sequence
as follows:
1. Alice Huang of Megaspeed, who imported $4.8 billion
worth of chips, was suspected of being a mainland Chinese spy—though it was later
stated that this still remains unconfirmed.
2. An Nvidia vice president was alleged to be involved
in an extramarital affair with CEO Jensen Huang.
3. Jensen Huang has resigned.
4. Hundreds of NVIDIA employees have signed an
internal letter demanding the reinstatement of Jensen Huang as CEO and the
resignation of the board, with more than 1600 comments, the majority in full
support of reinstalling him[5].
II. Anomalies
- The Doubt
Regarding Compliance
No irregularities were found regarding Alice Huang’s chip
imports; Nvidia verified the inventory, and Singaporean authorities reviewed
the company’s business operations. Nvidia has stated there was nothing unusual
about its cooperation with Megaspeed and reported finding no evidence of chip
smuggling. As noted by the Atlantic Council, renting Nvidia chips in Southeast
Asia to Chinese firms like Alibaba is not in itself a violation of current US
export rules[6].
- The Identity
of Alice Huang
Rubio oversaw a classified memo that circulated among
cleared national security officials ahead of President Donald Trump's May 2026
trip to China. The memo flagged Alice Huang—a former executive at
Singapore-based data center firm Megaspeed—and her relationship with Jensen
Huang[7].
This was briefed to Trump, but Trump still decided to take Jensen Huang on his
trip to China. News about Alice Huang as a spy was leaked only shortly after
the Republicans lost the majority in the mid-term election. After Jensen
Huang’s resignation as CEO, Alice Huang continues to operate her businesses as
usual. According to Attorney Blanche, US Justice Department confirms that it has
not concluded Alice Huang was a Chinese spy.
- Response from
the Chinese Government
China denied it engaged in an attempt to ensnare
Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang, saying the spying allegations were unsubstantiated and
a smear campaign against Beijing. "The so-called Chinese spy allegation is
unsubstantiated. It is nothing but smears against China," Ministry of
Foreign Affairs spokesperson Guo Jiakun said[8].
- China’s Breakthroughs
in Its Own Chip Development
According to data from China’s Ministry of Industry
and Information Technology, China’s integrated circuit output reached 484.3
billion units by 2025, with more than 3,900 chip design companies, and the
localization rate for chips produced using mature processes approached 45
percent, making large-scale import of Nvidia’s chips unnecessary[9].
III. Possible Conspirators behind NY’s Reports and
Huang’s Resignation
- The
Republican Party
As the Republican Party lost the majority, it is
seeking to divert attention and find a scapegoat. This may not be voluntary,
yet it may have to do it to keep its power.
- Anthropic
Dario Amodei of Anthropic would like to see Nvidia fall
and also revenge on Huang's rebuttal to his comments on AI threats at a late-September
White House meeting with AI executives (with his connections to media and some
senators). Amodei has long pushed for strict restrictions on selling advanced
U.S. chips to China, while Huang opposed broad bans and supported regulated sales.
Anthropic refuses to rely solely on Nvidia. It actively trains and deploys
models on rival chips, including Google’s TPUs, Amazon’s Trainium, and custom
silicon from Broadcom. Nvidia’s biggest advantage has long been CUDA, its
proprietary software ecosystem that locks AI developers into its chips.
Anthropic recently used its Claude Mythos model to automatically port and
optimize Claude to run on rival AMD GPUs in just three days—a
feat that drastically lowers the barrier for companies to leave Nvidia's
hardware. Following Anthropic's record-breaking $1.5 trillion IPO debut on the
Nasdaq—and coinciding with Nvidia's leadership crisis after CEO Jensen Huang's
resignation—investors increasingly view Anthropic as a rival "king of
AI" competing for the same institutional investment dollars.
- The
Democratic Party
Although Democrats have won the majority, they are
looking for new ways of attack to force Trump down from power, and Jensen Huang
let them see a loophole. With Trump’s ties to Jensen Huang, and with his
insistence of talking him along on the China trip at the last moment, they
think they may nail the president down more easily.
- The
Competitors
Major rivals—most notably AMD and Alphabet—are
actively pushing to take market share from Nvidia following founder and CEO
Jensen Huang's resignation amid scandal and ongoing investigations. While
Nvidia still posts massive financial numbers, competitors are capitalizing on
its leadership transition and software shifts.
IV. Huang’s Possible Outcomes
- Reinstatement
as CEO
This could be highly unlikely in the short-term with
political interventions and the Board preoccupied with being accountable to the
Treasury Department.
- Some Kind of
Return
Huang could still be retained as a senior business and
technology consultant in addition to his influence as a founder of Nvidia.
- Quiet
Withdrawal
With more and more investigations and questioning, as
well as the Board busy to dodge bullets and shield risks, Huang may have to
withdraw to the back and take his role only as an individual shareholder.
People should bear in mind that Huang is being closely
watched. While being watched and overseen directly or indirectly, Huang’s
actions are limited unless dramatic political changes occur.
V. Implications
1. Impact on NVIDIA’s Corporate Governance and
Operating Performance
From a governance perspective, the incident exposed
NVIDIA’s long-standing “key person risk.” Jensen Huang holds only 3.58% of the
company’s shares, and since the company does not have a dual-class stock
structure, his authority relies primarily on the prestige he has built up over
his long tenure at the helm and the support of the board of directors. The
board demonstrated its independence during this incident: it swiftly launched
an independent investigation and unanimously rejected Jensen Huang’s request to
return to his position, with the chairman explicitly stating that he had “no
intention of reinstating him as CEO.” This marks a forced shift in governance
logic from “founder-driven” to “system-driven.” However, the company’s
long-standing flat management structure, the absence of a clear
second-in-command, and the unresolved issue of succession represent significant
short-term governance weaknesses.
In terms of business performance, short-term financial
data has not yet collapsed. The first earnings report following Jensen Huang’s
departure (Q3 of fiscal year 2027) showed that quarterly revenue surpassed $100
billion for the first time, reaching $115.8 billion, with the data center
business contributing approximately 93 percent; guidance for the next quarter
also exceeded expectations. However, a deeper concern lies in the tightening of
the financing ecosystem: NVIDIA has adjusted its supply chain financing
policies, no longer providing guarantees for the construction phase of data
centers, and has shifted its support for new cloud service providers to a
“selective and more prudent” approach. This reflects a contraction in the
customer financing network that previously relied on Jensen Huang’s personal
relationships; some small and medium-sized cloud service providers with heavy
debt burdens may face pressure to restructure.
2. Impact on U.S. Politics
Some observers have framed the incident against the
backdrop of political maneuvering following the U.S. midterm elections. Jensen
Huang maintained close ties with the Trump administration, and the controversy
erupted shortly after the Democrats’ victory in the midterms. Trump and Musk
publicly voiced support for Jensen Huang on multiple occasions in an attempt to
exert influence, but the board withstood external pressure. This indicates that
while political figures are eager to offer political support, such gestures
failed to directly overturn the board’s decision, which was based on internal
rules. However, this incident may also affect the relationship between the tech
industry and certain political forces.
3. Impact on the North American High-Tech Industry
The impact is primarily reflected in market confidence
and ecosystem interdependence. Following Jensen Huang’s resignation, NVIDIA’s
stock price fell by a cumulative 27.7% over seven trading days, erasing more
than $1 trillion in market capitalization and dragging down stock prices in the
U.S. AI hardware sector and among emerging cloud providers. A deeper implication
is that Huang was viewed as a key link in the “handshake deals” between NVIDIA
and its clients—such as emerging cloud providers like CoreWeave and Nebius. His
departure has prompted the market to reassess the stability of AI computing
power financing models that rely on personal relationships. Furthermore, this
incident may prompt tech companies to reflect on the governance risks posed by
excessive concentration of power in the hands of founders, accelerate the
industry’s focus on succession planning and institutional checks and balances,
and heighten attention to the impact of geopolitics on compliance management in
relevant sectors.
As a matter of fact, NVIDIA’s computing cards are
characterized by their narrow range of applications and high prices. To sustain
demand for these cards, Huang adopted a strategy of investing in large-model
companies, encouraging them to establish computing centers where they would
either purchase NVIDIA products for their own use or lease out computing power.
For small and medium-sized enterprises, he required them to use GPUs as
collateral to secure financing, which they would then use to purchase NVIDIA
products. The conditions necessary for this cycle to take hold are that
NVIDIA’s products consistently maintain a technological edge and that the
company enjoys a steady cash flow. However, with the emergence of DeepSeek in
China, Chinese products now offer affordable prices and open-source code, while
still maintaining a certain level of quality assurance. Therefore, to a certain
extent, selling chips to China actually benefits the United States. Without
U.S. chips, China would not only accelerate the development of its own products
and software systems but also break free from its dependence on U.S. products.
Consequently, not only would the United States be unable to profit from Chinese
companies, but Chinese firms might also eventually take business away from
companies in other countries.
4. Impact on the North American Economy
As a leading AI company with a market capitalization
in the trillions of dollars, NVIDIA’s sharp stock price volatility has directly
weighed on the broader U.S. stock market. Its market capitalization shrank by
nearly $900 billion in a single week—marking the largest weekly decline since
2008—and at one point dragged down the performance of the Nasdaq and the
S&P 500. A broader risk lies in the fact that AI investment is currently
one of the key growth narratives driving the U.S. economy, and NVIDIA is at the
core of this narrative. Leadership turmoil has sparked concerns about a
tightening of the AI computing power financing ecosystem. If small and
medium-sized cloud service providers slow their capital expenditures due to the
loss of implicit guarantees, this could ripple through the supply chain to
broader areas of technology investment.
5. Impact on the International Economic and Trade
Landscape
During his tenure, Jensen Huang played a unique
“buffer” role regarding chip export controls, actively lobbying for the
relaxation of restrictions on China in the interest of commercial gains. His
departure may weaken the forces within NVIDIA that have been pushing for
pragmatic cooperation with China. At the same time, the new CEO’s statement
that he “must respond very cautiously” to the complex situation surrounding
export controls suggests that policy maneuvering room may narrow. Furthermore,
the U.S. Department of Commerce’s rule restricting “remote access to advanced
semiconductors”—which was advanced around the same time as this
incident—extends controls from physical chips to computing power in overseas
data centers; NVIDIA has indicated that it needs time to assess the impact.
Overall, the incident itself does not directly alter the rules of geopolitics,
but it may cause companies to adopt a more conservative and compliance-oriented
approach to export control issues, reducing the scope for proactive lobbying
and thereby indirectly affecting the pace of U.S.-China technology and economic
interactions.
However, there is currently a noteworthy “discrepancy”
between U.S. and Canadian trade policies toward China: While the U.S. maintains
an overall framework of easing restrictions (such as extending Section 301
tariff exemptions for 178 Chinese goods, including machinery, components, and
photovoltaic manufacturing equipment, and suspending port fees on Chinese
ships), it continues to tighten controls in key technology sectors. For
example, as the Trump administration implemented tariff relief, it
simultaneously announced new regulations further restricting China’s access to
advanced AI chips from manufacturers such as NVIDIA. Canada, meanwhile, is
proactively easing its economic and trade relations with China to offset trade
pressure from the United States. On November 17, following a meeting between
Carney and Xi in Shenzhen, the two sides agreed to extend existing steel and
aluminum tariff exemptions for two years, and Canada further expanded the scope
of exemptions for Chinese steel and aluminum products. In exchange, China
provided additional tariff reductions on approximately 400 million Canadian
dollars’ worth of Canadian pork and seafood, and to date, Canada has restored
market access for more than 90% of trade previously subject to tariff
action – nearly $7.5 billion worth of Canadian exports[10].
At the same time, Canada has reduced tariffs on Chinese electric vehicles from
100% to 6.1%, with an initial annual quota of 49,000 vehicles[11].
Carney made it clear that if trade negotiations with the United States fail to
preserve an integrated North American automotive industry, Canada may turn to
cooperation with Chinese automakers—provided that substantial manufacturing
takes place in Canada and local supply chains are gradually established. This
is essentially laying the groundwork for a “post-North American integration”
industrial landscape. Canada’s pursuit of localization investments from Chinese
automakers offers a potential pathway for China’s electric vehicle industry to
indirectly enter the North American market. However, this channel faces strong
opposition within Canada (such as in Ontario), and its scale is far from
sufficient to replace the U.S. market. From a broader perspective, Canada’s
hedging strategy itself represents a centrifugal reaction to U.S. attempts to
force its allies to “align” their policies toward China in the supply chain,
thereby providing China with room to maintain a foothold for economic and trade
cooperation within the North American economic sphere. As for China-Canada
economic and trade relations, a window of opportunity has opened for easing
tensions, anchored by agricultural and natural resources and supported by
potential long-term localized investment in new energy vehicles. The depth of
this window will ultimately depend on how far Canada can go in balancing “North
American integration” with “pragmatic cooperation with China.” The impact of
this divergence on China is structural, rather than a simple “positive” or
“negative” development.
VI. Some Lessons to Be Learnt
- Win-Win vs
Lose-Lose
A global economy is not a zero-sum game, and open and
free trade enables us to achieve a win-win result. Thus, open and free trade
should be encouraged.
- Political
Intervention
Politics should not intervene in business activities
as they generally entail different areas, and the rule of law can make sure
businesses operate lawfully and fairly.
- Corporate
Governance
Corporate governance can be strengthened sustainably
with majority share-holding and a sound and smooth succession planning system.
Following his trips to China—including stops in
Hangzhou and Guangzhou ahead of summit talks—US Senator Steve Daines warned
that the U.S. may underestimate China's technology ecosystem and AI adoption.
In a post on Facebook, he noted that while the U.S. leads in frontier AI and
hardware, China is rapidly deploying AI in industry and everyday operations.
According to Briefs, Daines emphasized that the U.S. should not misjudge the
scale and sophistication of China's tech sector. Daines has described the
U.S.-China relationship as "too big to fail," citing the two
countries' economic weight and military/AI roles. In an interview reported by
Punchbowl News, Daines said summit talks should aim for "strategic
stability" and "de-confliction" channels amid the AI race.
Blaming in the public may cause discomfort and resistance, and private
consultation or discussion can bring forward more effective and practical
communication[12].
There is an Asian saying, “if you don't listen to the
advice of your elders, you'll suffer the consequences right away”. Here is such
advice: “every kingdom divided against itself is brought to desolation, and a
house divided against a house falls.” (Luke 11:17 NKJV)
[1]
Jensen Huang’s Extramarital Affair Sparks Espionage Speculation: How Are U.S.
and Chinese Media Telling the Same Story? (in Chinese) Voice of America, 10 Nov
2026. Please take a look at this article by clicking https://www.voachinese.com/a/one-scandal-two-narratives-how-u-s-and-chinese-media-cover-the-jensen-huang-affair-20261109/8220639.html.
[2]
Silicon Valley leaders call for reinstatement of Nvidia CEO with 'Stand With
Jensen' petition, and Signatories include Tesla CEO Elon Musk, Epic Games CEO
Tim Sweeney, Thomson Reuters, 16 Nov 2026. Please check https://www.cbc.ca/news/business/nvidia-ceo-huang-calls-reinstatements-9.7423555.
[3]
Daragh Thomas: Bill Ackman Lays Out How Nvidia Shareholders Could Bring Jensen
Huang Back as CEO, Benzinga, 18 Nov 2026. https://www.benzinga.com/markets/prediction-markets/26/11/63391467/nvidia-huang-return.
[4]
Sophia Cai and Brian Dabbs: Nvidia creates board committee to oversee export
controls, Politico, 17 Nov 2026,
https://www.politico.com/news/2026/11/17/nvidia-creates-board-committee-to-oversee-export-controls;
Wikipedia: Suzanne Nora Johnson, visited on 21 Nov 2026, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Suzanne_Nora_Johnson.
[6]
Maia Nikoladze and Lize de Kruijf: Beyond the spy scandal: What the
Nvidia-Megaspeed case reveals about export controls, Atlantic Council, 12 Nov
2026. https://www.atlanticcouncil.org/dispatches/beyond-the-spy-scandal-what-the-nvidia-megaspeed-case-reveals-about-export-controls/.
[7]
Yasin Gungor: Rubio oversaw classified memo alleging Nvidia CEO’s ties to
suspected Chinese intelligence operative: Report, Anadolu Ajansı, 9 Nov 2026.
Please read the article by clicking the following link: https://aa.com.tr/en/americas/rubio-oversaw-classified-memo-alleging-nvidia-ceo-s-ties-to-suspected-chinese-intelligence-operative-report/4116377.
[8]
Huizhong Wu: China dismisses claims of spy plot involving Nvidia CEO Huang as a
smear campaign, Associated Press, 9 Nov 2026. https://www.pbs.org/newshour/world/china-dismisses-claims-of-spy-plot-involving-nvidia-ceo-huang-as-a-smear-campaign.
[9]
Mind Observatory: 72.6%! Why Have China’s Chip Exports Skyrocketed (Chinese)?
Observer, 1 Apr 2026. https://www.guancha.cn/xinzhiguanchasuo/2026_04_01_812171.shtml.
[10]
Prime Minister Carney advances Canada’s strategic partnership with China across
trade, commerce, and culture, 17 Nov 2026, https://www.pm.gc.ca/en/news/news-releases/2026/11/17/prime-minister-carney-advances-canadas-strategic-partnership-china.
[11]
Prime Minister Carney forges new strategic partnership with the People’s
Republic of China focused on energy, agri-food, and trade, 16 Jan 2026, https://www.pm.gc.ca/en/news/news-releases/2026/01/16/prime-minister-carney-forges-new-strategic-partnership-peoples.
[12]
US, China Relationship 'Too Big to Fail,' Says Sen. Steve Daines, Bloomberg
Podcasts, 24 Sep 2026, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=msUUMyitC2c;
Richard Nixon Foundation: Why Tough Talks With China Happen Behind Closed Doors
| Sen. Steve Daines, 30 Oct 2026, click the following link for the article https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DdfqWJEoMZY.
